View/Download PDF
Original Article

Chiari malformation and types of basilar invagination with/without syringomyelia

Program in Health Sciences-IAMSPE; Department of Neurosurgery, Hospital Mandaqui, Brazil.
Department of Neurosurgery, Hospital Mandaqui, Brazil.
Program in Health Sciences-IAMSPE; Department of Neurosurgery, Hospital Mandaqui and Hospital do Servidor Publico Estadual - HSPE, São Paulo, Brazil.
Corresponding author: Ítalo Teles de Oliveira Filho, Rua Alameda dos Nhambiquaras, 122, Moema, 04090000 São Paulo, Brazil.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-Share Alike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as the author is credited and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
How to cite this article: Oliveira Filho IT, Fontoura EA, Romero PC, Botelho RV. Chiari malformation and types of basilar invagination with/ without syringomyelia. Surg Neurol Int 2019;10:206.



Craniometric studies document different subtypes of craniocervical junction malformations (CCJM). Here, we identified the different types and global signs and symptoms (SS) that correlated with these malformations while further evaluating the impact of syringomyelia.


Prospective data concerning SS and types of CCJM were evaluated in 89 patients between September 2002 and April 2014 using Bindal’s scale.


The mean Bindal’s scores of each type of CCJM were Chiari malformation (CM) = 74.6, basilar invagination Type 1 (BI1) = 78.5, and BI Type 2 (BI2) = 78. Swallowing impairment and nystagmus were more frequently present in the BI patients. Symptomatic burdens were higher in patients with syringomyelia and included weakness, extremity numbness, neck pain, dissociated sensory loss, and atrophy.


There were no statistically significant differences in SS between the different CCJM types. BI patients had more swallowing and nystagmus complaints versus CM patients, but there were no significant differences in clinical SS between BI1 and BI2 patients. Notably, those with attendant syringomyelia had a higher SS burden.


Arnold–Chiari malformation
Basilar impression
Neurologic manifestations
Signs and symptoms


Chiari malformations (CMs) and basilar invagination (BI – BI1 and BI2) are the most common craniocervical junction malformations (CCJM) seen in adults; both may also be associated with syringomyelia.[1,3,4,6,7]

BI1 is associated with craniocervical instability, odontoid insinuation toward the foramen magnum, and often anterior arch of the atlas assimilation.[2-4] BI Type 2 (BI2) is not associated with instability, but there is an exacerbation of the clivus canal angle and craniocervical kyphosis resulting in ventral compression of the brainstem and cranial nerves.[2-4] Syringomyelia is frequently encountered in all of these three types of CCJM and can be correlated with a variety of increased signs and symptoms (SS).[1] Here, we analyzed the different frequencies of SS, between these three CCJM subtypes with/without syringomyelia.


Study design

This study represented a cross-sectional evaluation of prospectively collected data conducted between September 2002 and April 2014 using Bindal’s scale. All patients filled out informed consent to enter in this study. The research protocol was approved by the research ethics committee (CAAE 32361614.6.0000.5551).

There were 89 consecutive symptomatic patients with CCJM; 46 (52%) had CM, 43 (48%) had BI; among those with BI: 13 (30%) had BI1, and 30 (70%) had BI2. Females represented 57% of the patients with CCJM (51 patients), and they averaged 47.7 years of age (range: 11–77 years). All exhibited varying degrees of SS attributed to neural structure/posterior fossa compression and/or CSF blockage. Syringomyelia was present in 44 (49%) of all CCJM (CM and BI) patients.

Definitions and diagnostic criteria of CM, B11, and B12 malformations [Figure 1]


Herniation (variable) of the cerebellar tonsils below the foramen magnum results in compression of the tonsils in the cisterna magna without odontoid insinuation toward the skull base.[3,4]

Figure 1:: Craniocervical junction malformations.


BI1: Odontoid insinuation toward the foramen magnum, violating the McRae line, associated with the anterior arch of the atlas assimilation, and craniocervical instability.[2-4,7]

BI2: Odontoid axis process above the Chamberlain line, without violation of the foramen magnum.[2-4,7]


Syringomyelia constitutes a fluid accumulation around the spinal cord central canal, identified as intramedullary hypersignals on T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).[1,4]

Assessment of SS of CCJM

Bindal’s standardized scale longitudinally evaluated CCJM patients’ clinical manifestations and provided the following score for follow-up comparisons; each sign or symptom received a score of 10, and the score (symptomatic burden) was defined as the sum of the SS presented by the patients [Table 1].[1]

Table 1:: Bindal’s scale.

Statistical evaluation

Bindal’s scores for the three types of malformations were compared using ANOVA (the Kruskal–Wallis test).

SS were described by percentages and were compared between types using the Chi-squared test; this was similarly applied to patients with/without syringomyelia [Graphs 1-5 and Table 2].

Graph 1:: Prevalence of Chiari malformation signs and symptoms.
Graph 2:: Prevalence of basilar invagination Type 1 signs and symptoms.
Graph 3:: Prevalence of basilar invagination Type 2 signs and symptoms.
Graph 4:: The mean Bindal’s score for each type of craniocervical junction malformations.
Graph 5:: The mean Bindal’s score for each craniocervical junction malformation type with and without syringomyelia.
Table 2:: Prevalence of signs and symptoms of craniocervical junction malformations as measured using the Chi-squared test.


Prevalent SS among three CCJM malformations

Predominant SS for patients with these three malformations (CCJM, B11, and B12) included neck pain, ataxia, numbness, and weakness of the extremities (e.g., with added headaches for CM patients and sleep apnea for BI patients). For CM patients, SS in descending order included neck pain, headache, and numbness of extremities followed by weakness [Graph 1]. For patients with B11, SS in descending order included weakness and neck pain, ataxia, sleep apnea, and extremity numbness [Graph 2]. For BI2 patients, SS included (descending order) weakness, ataxia, nystagmus, sleep apnea, extremity numbness, neck pain, and headache [Graph 3].

The mean Bindal’s score for each type of CCJM was 74.6 for CM, 78.5 for BI1, and 78 for BI2 (Kruskal–Wallis test, P = 0.9) [Graph 4]. There were significant differences in SS, swallowing difficulty (P = 0.03) and nystagmus (P = 0.007) for the three groups [Table 2].

SS for patients with/without syringomyelia

The mean Bindal’s score was 69.3 for the patients without syringomyelia and 83.4 for the syringomyelic patients (Mann–Whitney U-test; P = 0.054) [Graph 5]. Weakness (SS), extremity numbness, neck pain, dissociated sensory loss, and atrophy were significantly more frequent (P < 0.05) in the patients with syringomyelia.


Our understanding of CCJM (e.g., CM, B11, and B12) has evolved with the introduction of computed tomography, MRI, linear and angular craniometric studies, and genetic and embryological studies.[2-4] Notably, SS for each of these three entities differ. Although the current study found no statistically significant differences in the incidence of sleep apnea between the CCJM types, others indicated that sleep apnea was more frequent and intense in BI patients.[5] In 43 patients with atlantoaxial dislocation and CCJM, Shuhui et al. found the following SS to be prevalent (in descending order): weakness (93%), cervical motor limitations (88%), limb paresthesia (98%), neck and shoulder pain (58%), ataxia (42%), vertigo (23%), and respiratory difficulties (7%).[8]

Goel showed that the following symptoms were more predominant in BI1 patients: paresthesias (55%), spinothalamic dysfunction (36%), cervicalgia (77%), and torticollis (41%). The study also reported that BI2 physiopathology was the same as for CM, largely attributable to the diminished cranial fossa volume contributing to SS.[4] Our results showed that the only SS differences in the three subtypes of CCJM were swallowing difficulties (P = 0.03) and nystagmus (P = 0.007) in the BI patients.

Bindals’ scale

Bindal’s scale was created to quantify SS, and in this study, no differences were found in the SS burden between the three types of CCJM, but SS burdens were uniformly increased in all patients with accompanying syringomyelia.[1,4]


For the three types of CCJM, swallowing difficulties and nystagmus were more prevalent in BI versus CM, while all CCJM patients with syringomyelia had higher frequencies of weakness, extremity numbness, neck pain, dissociated sensory loss, and atrophy.

Financial support and sponsorship


Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.


  1. , , . Chiari I malformation: Classification and management. Neurosurgery. 1995;37:1069-74
    [Google Scholar]
  2. , . Basilar Invagination: Cranio-cervical kyphosis rather than prolapse from the upper cervical spine. J Neurol Neuromed. 2017;2:15-9
    [Google Scholar]
  3. , . The odontoid process invagination in normal subjects, chiari malformation and basilar invagination patients: Pathophysiologic correlations with angular craniometry. Surg Neurol Int. 2015;6:118
    [Google Scholar]
  4. . Basilar invagination, chiari malformation, syringomyelia: A review. Neurol India. 2009;57:235-46
    [Google Scholar]
  5. , , , , , , . Upper airway dimensions in patients with craniocervical junction malformations with and without sleep apnea. A pilot case-control study. Arq Neuropsiquiatr. 2015;73:336-41
    [Google Scholar]
  6. . Chiari I malformation with and without basilar invagination: A comparative study. Neurosurg Focus. 2015;38:E12
    [Google Scholar]
  7. , , . Basilar invagination, basilar impression, and platybasia: Clinical and imaging aspects. Curr Pain Headache Rep. 2016;20:49
    [Google Scholar]
  8. , , , , . Surgical management of adult reducible atlantoaxial dislocation, basilar invagination and chiari malformation with syringomyelia. Turk Neurosurg. 2016;26:615-21
    [Google Scholar]
Show Sections